Sign In

Article Information

  • The Supremacy Clause versus S.B. 1070: Can Arizona's Strict Illegal Immigration Law Withstand Constitutional Challenge?

    Trackers searching for Rob Krentz could not locate him using a thermal imager. His body was too cold. Rob Krentz was dead. Mr. Krentz was a member of “one of the best-known and oldest ranching families . . . in southeast Arizona.” On March 27, 2010, he was found dead on his 35,000-acre ranch after suffering fatal gunshot wounds. Prior to his death, Mr. Krentz was riding around his property in an all-terrain vehicle when he radioed to his brother that he “was aiding someone he believed to be an illegal immigrant.” Presently, the authorities are unsure who killed Mr. Krentz. However, because of the “radio transmission . . . and heavy drug and illegal immigrant trafficking in that area,” it is widely suspected that Mr. Krentz was killed by a cross-border drug smuggler or human trafficker. Prior to Mr. Krentz’s death, the Support Our Law Enforcement and Safe Neighborhoods Act (S.B. 1070) was introduced into the Arizona State Legislature. This strict immigration measure was initiated largely “because border authorities [in Arizona] arrest more people and seize more drugs than . . . any other state.” After Mr. Krentz’s death, he became the “face” of the Arizona immigration debate. Some politicians even pushed to name S.B. 1070 the “Rob Krentz Law.” In fact, one month after Mr. Krentz's mysterious death, Arizona Governor Jan Brewer signed S.B. 1070 into law.